Fascism is Marching, but It’s from the Left?

In recent years, the term fascism has been hurled across the political spectrum, often directed at conservative movements. However, many argue that the true threat of fascism is emerging from the left, not the right. This notion, though controversial, challenges the mainstream narrative and brings forth critical insights into the state of politics in America today.

The historical roots of fascism are often linked to authoritarianism, ultranationalism, and suppression of dissent. Traditionally associated with far-right regimes like Mussolini’s Italy or Hitler’s Germany, fascism is more complex and has evolved in various ways. In modern political discourse, the term is frequently used as a weaponized label, often applied inaccurately to undermine opposing viewpoints. However, the fascist tendencies that are feared may now be materializing through leftist ideologies and movements.

These days anything left of fascism is considered”left” pic.twitter.com/HtnbEEqveA

— Fred (@uncleFredsTweet) September 29, 2024

Fascism, at its core, is marked by a desire for a powerful, centralized state that suppresses opposition and controls many aspects of life. According to scholars, such as those cited by the Hoover Institution, modern-day leftist movements are increasingly resembling this model. These movements often emphasize state control, whether through economic regulation or enforcing ideological conformity, pushing back on individual liberties and free markets in the name of social justice or environmentalism. This emerging authoritarianism from the left, while not identical to historic fascism, raises concerns about the trajectory of progressive politics​.

One of the key arguments for the rise of left-wing fascism is how certain ideologies now advocate for censorship and violent suppression of dissenting opinions. Progressive activists and organizations often push for restrictions on speech that they deem "hate speech" or misinformation. This tactic, while framed as promoting inclusivity and protecting marginalized groups, echoes fascist principles of controlling dialogue and enforcing ideological purity. For example, suppression of alternative views, especially on issues like climate change or identity politics, aligns with a fascistic desire to eliminate opposition.

This is the fascism and tyranny the left practices. And which they say Trump will do and which he never did while in office for four years. https://t.co/CGcAtIWUZQ

— wrytr (@wrytyrs) September 26, 2024

Additionally, the normalization of political violence has been seen in leftist movements like Antifa, which operates as a loosely organized paramilitary group. Antifa's confrontations with right-wing protesters, as well as its promotion of political violence, have drawn comparisons to the street brawlers of 1930s fascist movements. The storming of Michigan’s Capitol in 2020 and the more prominent January 6 riot are often highlighted as examples of violent right-wing fascism, yet the normalization of such tactics is not confined to the political right. Leftist groups frequently use these same strategies, further blurring the lines.

Moreover, the influence of left-wing policies on economic systems also evokes fascist tendencies. Progressive policies often call for increased state control over industries in the name of equality and environmental sustainability. Syndicalism and corporatism—economic models historically linked to fascist regimes—are increasingly popular among left-leaning politicians and activists. These policies may stem from a desire to address inequalities, but their methods reflect a disturbing parallel to past fascist economics, which sought to control industry and suppress free market competition​.

What many fear today is not a fascist takeover akin to 20th-century dictatorships, but the slow march toward a highly regulated, ideologically controlled society. The left’s increasing reliance on cancel culture, censorship, and calls for expansive government intervention aligns with elements of fascism, particularly in their efforts to create a homogenized society under centralized control.

The left’s authoritarian streak, combined with the mainstream media’s failure to address it, leaves many concerned. As noted by political scientists, the growing support for state intervention in everyday life, coupled with the violent suppression of dissent, is an alarming trend that echoes the rise of fascist politics. The key to avoiding this fate is a recommitment to individual liberties, free expression, and open debate—values that are increasingly under assault from progressive forces.